
The SRA’s proposed client money safeguard reforms are not just technical rule changes. They go to a much bigger question: who really has power inside a law firm, and can the COLP and COFA properly challenge the people who run it?
That was the central theme of our latest JBL Compliance webinar, where Jonathon Bray, Sophie Cisler, Liz Bond and Edward Marshall discussed the SRA’s proposed changes to accountants’ reports and the new restrictions on who can act as COLP and COFA.
The proposals are still subject to approval by the Legal Services Board. But if they are approved, firms will need to think carefully about their governance arrangements, role holder eligibility and client money controls before the rules come into force.
What is being proposed?
There are two main strands to the reforms.
First, firms that hold client money will need to provide more information to the SRA about their accountants’ reports. The main change is visibility. The SRA wants a clearer picture of which firms have obtained them, which firms are exempt, and whether reports are being submitted on time. Late or non-submission may also lead to fixed financial penalties.
As Liz Bond explained during the webinar, this is in some ways a return to the pre-2014 position, when accountants’ reports were routinely submitted to the SRA. Since then, only qualified reports have generally had to be submitted, which left an obvious gap: the regulator could see reports that disclosed problems, but had less visibility over whether firms were obtaining reports at all.
The second, and far more controversial, proposal is the restriction on who can act as COLP and COFA.
The draft rules apply where a firm has annual turnover of more than £600,000, or has held or received client money with a maximum statement or passbook balance exceeding £2 million.
For firms with more than one manager or owner, an individual cannot be COLP or COFA if they are a manager or owner who has authority, whether under the firm’s constitution, governance arrangements or usual practice, to determine or direct significant management decisions relating to the structure or running of the firm.
That wording is crucial.
It means firms cannot simply look at their LLP agreement, partnership deed, articles or shareholders’ agreement and assume the answer is there. They also need to look at how decisions are actually made in practice.
Who approves spending? Who controls recruitment? Who sets the risk appetite? Who signs off on systems? Who has real influence in the boardroom? Who do people defer to?
That is where this becomes a governance exercise, not just a role holder eligibility question.
Accountants’ reports: sensible, but not a complete answer
The panel was broadly supportive of the accountants’ report proposals. They should give the SRA better visibility and close a gap that has existed since routine submission ended.
But we also discussed the limits of accountants’ reports.
A report can be a useful diagnostic tool, particularly if it identifies weaknesses that the firm then addresses promptly. Liz made the point that, in her SRA investigations experience, firms were in a much better position where they had already taken remedial action before the regulator came knocking.
But accountants’ reports are not a complete safeguard. They are historic. By the time a report is prepared, reviewed and submitted, it may relate to a period many months earlier. That is not going to detect a serious client account problem that happens suddenly.
There is also a question about quality. Reporting on solicitors’ client accounts is a specialist area. Not every accountant does it regularly, and a clean accountants’ report does not automatically mean that all client money risks are well controlled.
So, although the proposed declaration process is sensible, firms should not treat the accountants’ report as the whole answer. The report should sit within a wider system of client account controls, breach recording, reconciliation, review and governance oversight.
The real issue: power, influence and challenge
The most important part of the webinar was the discussion about COLPs and COFAs.
The SRA’s policy aim is easy to understand. It is concerned about firms where too much power sits with one person, particularly where that person owns the firm, controls management decisions, oversees client money and is also responsible for compliance reporting.
The problem is the drafting. The rule does not simply refer to unilateral control. It refers to someone who can determine or direct significant management decisions relating to the structure or running of the firm.
That potentially captures far more people.
As Ed Marshall pointed out, this could affect ordinary partners, directors, senior managers and others on management boards. Sophie Cisler also highlighted the tension with the SRA’s existing approach to compliance officer approval. When firms apply for a new COLP or COFA, the SRA has historically wanted assurance that the person has enough influence, seniority, access and authority to do the job properly.
There is an obvious contradiction here.
On one hand, the compliance officer must be senior enough to influence the firm. On the other hand, too much influence may now make them ineligible.
That is the core problem with the proposed drafting. If the rule pushes firms to appoint someone who is technically eligible but has less authority, less information and less confidence to challenge senior management, it may weaken the compliance officer regime rather than strengthen it.
Sole owner-manager firms: clear on paper, difficult in practice
The draft rules are clearest for sole owner-manager firms.
If the firm’s annual turnover is more than £600,000, the sole owner-manager cannot be COLP or COFA.
If turnover is £600,000 or less, but the firm exceeds the £2 million client money threshold, the sole owner-manager cannot be COFA, although the draft rule does not prevent them from being COLP.
In policy terms, the SRA’s concern is understandable. If one person owns the firm, runs the firm, controls the client account and reports to the regulator, there is an obvious question about checks and balances.
But in practice, this may be very difficult for small firms. The sole owner-manager may be the person who understands the firm best. They may be the person who knows the clients, the finances, the staff, the systems, the weaknesses and the history. Removing the compliance role from that person may leave the firm looking for someone who is less experienced, less embedded and less able to challenge.
There is also a commercial point. Turnover is not profit. A £600,000 turnover firm may not have the budget to recruit one or two senior compliance role holders simply to deal with eligibility under the proposed rules.
This creates a real risk that firms appoint someone because they need a name on the form, rather than because that person is the right person to protect clients and challenge management.
External COLPs and COFAs: solution or new risk?
Several audience questions focused on whether firms might look to external or fractional COLPs and COFAs.
Technically, there may be circumstances where a consultant or someone acting under a contract for services can fall within the relevant definition. But the panel was cautious.
An external role holder may not be embedded in the firm. They may not see what is happening day to day. They may not be present when decisions are made. They may depend on the firm telling them what they need to know.
That creates its own risk. A compliance officer who is not embedded, does not have full access to information and cannot attend the right meetings may become a title appointment rather than a meaningful safeguard.
There is also a recruitment market problem. The SRA can change the rules, but it cannot create a ready-made pool of experienced COLPs and COFAs who are willing to take personal regulatory responsibility without real power.
Smaller partnerships: the hardest category?
For smaller traditional partnerships and LLPs, the proposals may be especially difficult.
Take a firm with five to ten partners. The COLP or COFA is a partner. Major decisions are usually taken collectively. On paper, no single partner can determine everything. But in practice, certain people may carry more influence: the founder, the managing partner, the finance partner, the rainmaker, or the person everyone usually defers to.
Can the firm say that no individual determines or directs significant management decisions?
Possibly. But it needs to evidence that conclusion.
This is where “usual practice” becomes important. Firms will need to review not only their formal governance documents, but also how they actually behave.
Sophie suggested a two-stage approach. First, the firm should carry out its own internal review. Gather the constitutional documents. Look at recent significant decisions. Ask who was involved, who drove the decision, who had final say and whether the process matched the documents.
Second, firms may want an external review or sense-check. That can help identify gaps, risk areas and inconsistencies between the written governance model and day-to-day reality.
This could be a healthy exercise. Many firms have grown from one or two founders into more complex practices without ever properly revisiting how decisions should be made. But it will require honesty.
If the documents say one thing and practice says another, the SRA is likely to be interested in practice.
Larger firms: more people, but not necessarily easier
For larger firms, the issue looks different.
They may have risk teams, compliance teams, management boards and more obvious alternatives. On paper, finding someone eligible may be easier.
But the risk is that the role is pushed down from the real decision-making table.
A Head of Risk, General Counsel or senior compliance lawyer may have technical expertise. But if they are not in the room when strategic decisions are made, they may only be brought in when the decision has effectively already been taken.
Sophie put it well during the webinar: the useful question is “should we be doing this?” The unhelpful question is “the deal completes tomorrow, how do we make this compliant?”
That distinction captures the problem. Compliance officers need to be involved early enough to influence decisions, not just late enough to tidy them up.
If the new rules encourage firms to distance COLPs and COFAs from real management power, there is a risk that they are told less, involved later and held responsible anyway.
That is not better governance.
Will separation of powers actually reduce risk?
A theme from the discussion was that separation of titles is not the same as separation of power.
The SRA is right to be concerned about client money failures. Law firms cannot keep absorbing major collapses through the Compensation Fund. Public trust in the profession is damaged each time something goes badly wrong.
But the question is whether these proposals address the real risk.
Several points came out of the discussion. First, many serious client money failures are not simply caused by one person being COLP or COFA. If there is fraud, collusion or deliberate concealment, a less powerful compliance officer may not stop it.
Secondly, accountants’ reports are useful but historic. They will not catch a serious problem that happens suddenly.
Thirdly, the SRA may need to focus more directly on payment controls, authorisation controls and real-time client account safeguards. Several attendees raised the point that dual sign-off or multiple authorisations for client account payments may be more directly connected to the risk the SRA is trying to reduce.
Fourthly, accountability becomes complicated if the role holder is deliberately kept away from the decision-making structure. If a COLP or COFA is not allowed into the room, does not receive the information and has no real influence, how meaningful is their accountability?
The risk is that the reforms create an attractive regulatory theory, but a difficult practical reality.
Questions from attendees
The chat and Q&A showed how many firms are already trying to work through the practical consequences.
Common questions included:
- If a small firm has two or three partners, and all of them make significant decisions, who can be COLP or COFA?
- If important decisions are made collectively at board level, does that mitigate the rule?
- If a director is currently COLP and has power to direct significant management decisions, will they need to resign?
- If the role is passed down to an employee solicitor, will that person realistically have enough time, authority and support to do the job?
- Would an external COLP or COFA be sufficiently involved in the business to identify risks?
- Are the proposals pushing firms towards dedicated career COLPs and COFAs?
- Should the SRA be focusing more on firms with the highest client account balances and requiring stronger payment controls?
- When will the LSB decide whether the rules are approved?
Those questions show the practical difficulty. This is not just resistance to change. Many firms accept that client money safeguards need strengthening. Their concern is whether this rule, as drafted, will achieve that objective.
What firms should do now
Although the rules are not yet in force, firms should not wait until implementation before doing any work.
The sensible first step is a threshold check. Was the firm’s turnover more than £600,000 in the most recently completed accounting period? Did the firm hold or receive client money with a maximum balance exceeding £2 million? If the £2 million threshold was exceeded, was that part of ordinary business or an incidental spike caused by an unusual transaction?
The second step is a role holder review. Who is currently COLP? Who is COFA? Are they owners, managers, directors, members or partners? What powers do they have on paper? What influence do they have in practice?
The third step is a governance analysis. Firms should review their articles, LLP agreement, partnership agreement, shareholders’ agreement, board terms of reference, delegated authority framework, bank mandates and committee structures.
But they should also ask the harder questions:
- Who actually makes decisions?
- Who approves spending?
- Who controls recruitment?
- Who sets the risk appetite?
- Who controls client account processes?
- Who can override others?
- Who is dominant in the boardroom?
- Who do people defer to?
The fourth step is succession planning. If the current COLP or COFA may not be eligible, who could realistically take the role? Not just who could be named on the form, but who has the competence, confidence, information, authority and support to do the job properly.
The fifth step is to tighten accountants’ report processes. Firms need to know whether they need a report, whether they are exempt, who owns the process, when the report is due, what needs to be submitted and what happens internally when the report is received.
How JBL Compliance can help
We are already helping firms think through the practical impact of these proposals.
If you want help analysing your current governance arrangements, assessing whether your COLP and COFA can continue, or working out how decision-making actually operates in your firm, we can help.
That might include:
- reviewing your ownership and management structure;
- checking your current COLP and COFA arrangements;
- reviewing constitutional and governance documents;
- mapping who has authority in practice;
- identifying whether the proposed rules may apply;
- helping you document your analysis; and
- advising on practical options if your current role holders may no longer be eligible.
The important thing is to do this early. If the rules are approved, there may be a large number of firms needing to review or change role holders at the same time. That could create pressure on internal succession planning and on SRA approval timescales.
If you would like us to help you sense-check your position, please get in touch.


